Every post on this blog, with a short summary of each. Starred posts are the ones I consider most important.
First blog post
January 27, 2017
I introduce the blog, which my brother gave me for my birthday, as a place to move longer takes off Facebook and test beliefs through conversation rather than tribal scoring.
Trade and tariffs (2017)
Published January 27, 2017 – January 29, 2017.
Tariffs Transfer Wealth From the Poor To The Rich
January 27, 2017
Tariffs are sold as opening foreign markets, leveling the playing field, and saving jobs, but I argue that a rarely discussed effect is to transfer income and wealth from poorer Americans to richer ones.
More On Trade
January 29, 2017
I share a Cafe Hayek post whose charts I found useful for dispelling some popular misconceptions about trade.
Videos With Which I Have Been Involved
January 29, 2017
I note my long involvement with the Free To Choose Network and point to PBS programs I helped with, including Power To The People, Suffer No Fools, and Free Or Equal, plus upcoming work such as The Human Cost of Welfare.
Wealth ★
Published February 4, 2017 – February 5, 2017.
Wealth
February 4, 2017
I sort out common misunderstandings of wealth, including how relative it is and why creating more than one consumes is a moral obligation if one is able. I argue that we should support wealth creation because it raises living standards, especially for descendants, even though it has costs as well as benefits.
Wealth Creation. No Happiness, Why Bother?
February 5, 2017
This is the first of two replies to a friend’s question: if wealth does not make people happier, why make so much of it? I argue that the pursuit of happiness and useful work for others matter more than a happiness score, and that a government barred from blocking that pursuit fares better.
Wealth Creation – It’s For The Children, and their children, and their children. . . .
February 5, 2017
In this second reply, I take up the claim that wealth makes nations fat, lazy, and doomed, as Rome was. I argue that wealth creation is still worth pursuing because of what it can mean for our children and theirs, even if prosperity also brings decadence risks.
Investment Income and Universal Basic Income Are Not “Basically The Same”
February 6, 2017
I reject the claim that capital gains are “basically the same” as a universal basic income. Investment income is a return on capital that had to be produced and put at risk, not a government cash grant.
Greed ★
February 15, 2017
Calling companies greedy for not paying more is usually a sloppy use of the word. I sort out what “excessive desire” even means, and why employers of low-skilled workers are typically not greedy in the moral sense people intend.
Equal Rights or Equal Outcomes?
February 25, 2017
The Declaration and the Constitution protect equal rights under the law, not equal economic outcomes. I argue that treating unequal results as proof of injustice, and then selling political favors to “fix” them, undermines the liberal ideals that actually raised living standards.
The Truth Is Hard For The New York Times
March 5, 2017
A New York Times Oscars ad claimed “The Truth Is Hard,” but I argue the paper often reports less than the whole truth and peddles half-truths that fit its point of view, rather than seeking the net effects that matter.
Income Inequality Is More Than It’s Cracked Up To Be ★
March 13, 2017
Like the sun, income inequality causes harm, but we would not fare well without it. I distinguish inequality that comes from theft or political favor, which is evil, from inequality that rewards useful work and is part of how prosperity is created.
Obamacare – Repeal, or Repeal and Replace?
Published April 5, 2017 – April 12, 2017. A third part was planned but not published; the “Two Paths for America” posts grew out of that work.
Obamacare – Repeal, or Repeal and Replace? PART I
April 5, 2017
Part I of a planned healthcare series: the U.S. system was unsustainable before Obamacare and is even less sustainable with it. The country faces a choice between a collectivist path and a more free-market path, each with tradeoffs rather than a complete solution.
Obamacare – Repeal, or Repeal and Replace? PART II
April 12, 2017
Part II argues that politicians are making healthcare worse by doubling down on the idea that the country can pay for all the care every citizen wants on demand. I warn that nationalizing care would also starve the medical research on which the world depends.
Two Paths for America
Published May 6, 2017 – August 14, 2017.
Two Paths for America
May 6, 2017
While writing a planned third Obamacare post, I stepped back to a larger choice: whether America remains a limited-government, liberty-oriented country or becomes more collectivist. I argue that extolling individual liberty produces better outcomes, and that a further collectivist step on healthcare could be very hard to reverse.
A Comment Worthy of a Post
May 7, 2017
A friend’s comment on “Two Paths for America” said the argument over collectivized healthcare will never be settled until America tries it. I reply that there would be no agreed counterfactual, and that collectivizing care would almost certainly slow medical innovation.
More On Two Paths for America
August 14, 2017
A follow-up to “Two Paths for America,” drawn from a Facebook post during the 2016 campaign. I ask readers to choose between shared gains in purchasing power with a wider gap, or losses for almost everyone with a narrower gap, and argue that the first path, Option A, is better for the poor than the redistributive Option B.
“Solutions”
June 1, 2017
A question in an Irish pub about whether fracking is “safe” leads me to a larger point: public policy has no unalloyed solutions, only tradeoffs. Making things too safe, I argue, has high costs of its own, including delayed medicines and other harms.
“You will always have the poor among you. . . .”
June 8, 2017
I examine Jesus’s words about the poor always being among us in the context of U.S. healthcare and poverty. Official poverty measures that look only at cash income, I argue, obscure how much better off poor Americans are than the label suggests, especially once non-cash aid is counted.
Income Inequality — the Gap Is Not as Large as You May Think.
June 19, 2017
A follow-up to my posts on poverty and income inequality. I argue that the meaningful standard of living of America’s poor and middle-income people has advanced faster than that of the rich, and that the consumption gap is smaller than income statistics make it look.
The Timeless Constitution
July 4, 2017
On Independence Day, I answer the claim that the Constitution is too old to guide a modern world. Human nature has not changed, I argue, so the timeless principles it was designed to protect remain the right guide.
Where is the Empathy?
July 6, 2017
A response to Fr. James Martin’s tweet, amid debate over slowing the growth of welfare, that politicians lack empathy for the poor and sick. Wanting to help is commendable, but I argue that handing that duty to Caesar through welfare is a failed idea, and that urging the state to take other people’s money does not fulfill a personal obligation.
Non Sequiturs on Parade
Published July 13, 2017 – December 4, 2017. A nine-part rebuttal, including the conclusion, of Steve Roth’s article “Why Welfare and Redistribution Saves Capitalism from Itself.”
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART I
July 13, 2017
Part I of my rebuttal of Steve Roth’s claim that welfare and redistribution save capitalism. I start with his assertion that no country ever joined the rich-country club without massive redistribution, which I argue is false because those countries became rich first and only then could afford large welfare states.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART II
July 14, 2017
Part II takes up Roth’s dare to name a thriving country that rejected “freedom-sapping” social programs. I argue he has the sequence backward: poor countries cannot redistribute their way into the rich club, and their best chance is more open trade, not more redistribution.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART III
July 15, 2017
Part III challenges Roth’s claim that market capitalism inevitably concentrates wealth into fewer and fewer hands. Forbes data on the growing numbers of millionaires and billionaires, I argue, point the other way.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART IV
July 19, 2017
Part IV is a respite from cataloging Roth’s errors. I credit him for acknowledging capitalism’s immense benefits, agree that income inequality can cause real problems, and begin examining the presumptions behind his case for redistribution.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART V
July 26, 2017
Part V returns to the central question: did Roth actually explain why welfare and redistribution save capitalism from itself? I use his article as a specimen of leftist fallacies, not as a personal attack, and argue that giving government more money and control has not produced the better outcomes he claims.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART VI
July 28, 2017
Part VI looks at Roth’s use of OECD “rich club” countries and their social spending, including his praise of Germany. I note that none of those countries have pure market economies, that the scale of redistribution varies, and that those facts do not prove his claim that redistribution saves capitalism.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART VII
August 4, 2017
Part VII turns to Roth’s late attempt to prove his title claim with the idea that poorer people spend more of an extra dollar than richer people. I argue that this “decreasing marginal propensity to spend” point does not show that redistribution saves capitalism from itself.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – PART VIII
August 22, 2017
Part VIII takes up Roth’s claim that the New Deal saved capitalism from itself by sharing the wealth and lifting the country out of the Depression. I argue that this is a leftist myth, not an explanation of why redistribution saves capitalism.
Non Sequiturs on Parade – CONCLUSION
December 4, 2017
The conclusion of the Roth series reviews what Parts I through VIII showed and returns to the question the series asked. I argue that Roth never explained why welfare and redistribution save capitalism, and I set out why spending so much time on the article was still worthwhile.
“Progressives” and the Constitution
July 27, 2017
A Facebook memory about Hillary Clinton preferring the word “progressive” leads me to the early-20th-century Progressive agenda. I argue that movement sought to loosen constitutional limits on government, contrary to the founders’ design for checking flawed rulers, and that this is why I said Trump would be terrible but Hillary would be worse.
HURRICANE HARVEY AND ME
November 9, 2017
Unlike my usual policy posts, this one explains a long blogging hiatus. I recount, as best I can remember amid “hurricane brain,” how Hurricane Harvey flooded our family in Houston, and I thank the people who helped us.
“He’s a Hater!”
December 10, 2017
The popular accusation “he’s a hater” is often ridiculous, and the accuser is often as guilty of hostility as the accused. I argue that hatred can be good or bad depending on its object, and that the better rule is to love the sinner and hate the sin, answering calm disagreement with argument rather than demonization.
FDR
Published December 21, 2017 – February 1, 2018.
FDR – PART I: Is FDR Still a Big Deal?
December 21, 2017
Part I, inspired by John Cogan’s work on entitlements, asks why FDR still matters so long after his death. I argue that a mythologized FDR remains the superhero of the left’s narrative, and that those myths still shape policy debates today.
FDR – PART II: What FDR Did
February 1, 2018
Part II asks what FDR actually did, and whether those deeds can validate modern leftist policies. I set out the beliefs that narrative needs to be true—unlimited government doing good, the unimportance of debt, a right to economic security—and begin sorting out the record behind the myths.
A Goldberg Article Too Good and Timely Not To Share Here
December 24, 2017
I interrupt the FDR series to share Jonah Goldberg’s essay “America and the ‘Original Position,’” which I found too good not to pass along amid confusion about the newly passed tax bill. I also note how his claim that human ingenuity is the engine of wealth creation sits alongside my earlier claim that income inequality is such an engine.
Tax cuts and employee compensation
Published December 30, 2017 – January 8, 2018.
Tax Cuts and Employee Compensation
December 30, 2017
I again defer FDR to sort out a confusion about the tax bill: the idea that if profitable companies already fail to raise wages, tax cuts will not either. I argue that employers do not simply set pay by generosity, and I sort out how taxes and labor-market competition affect compensation.
Comments about Tax Cuts and Employee Compensation
January 8, 2018
I reproduce and organize a long exchange with Amandeep Singh Sandhawalia about my tax-cut post, covering immigration and wages, what firms do with profits, and CEO pay, so readers of the blog can see the arguments.
Fake news and fact-checking (the London embassy tweet)
Published January 14, 2018 – January 17, 2018.
A Prime Example of Fake News
January 14, 2018
Using a viral poster about a Trump tweet canceling a London trip over the U.S. embassy deal, I distinguish the real news in the tweet from the fake-news spin around it. I argue the press overshadowed Trump’s claims about a bad real-estate deal with inaccurate or misplaced attacks.
An Example of Fake Fact Checking
January 17, 2018
A follow-up arguing that PolitiFact botched its “mostly false” rating of the same embassy tweet. I walk through Trump’s actual claims about the sale of the old London embassy and the cost of the new one, and I argue the fact check let bias get in the way of the whole truth.
Prosecution of Steele – Small Potatoes?
February 4, 2018
The House FISA memo said Christopher Steele lied to the FBI, which is a crime. I argue that declining to prosecute him would be no small matter: it would show Washington elites protecting their own and raise doubt about whether the FBI can investigate its own misconduct.
“Trickle Down”
February 9, 2018
A slightly edited 2014 Facebook post on how “trickle down” actually works. I use the fall in the real cost of smartphone-like technology to argue that policies which slow innovation keep better goods expensive and delay the moment when ordinary people can afford them.
Who’s the Wiser?
February 19, 2018
I compare a Trump tweet about Russian Facebook spending with Adam Schiff’s reply. Trump’s tweet has problems, I argue, but Schiff’s response is worse, because it never seriously addresses the claim that Russia’s effort was small next to slanted mainstream coverage that helped Clinton.
The Florida shooting and school policy
Published February 27, 2018 – March 29, 2018.
Prelude To A Post About The Florida Shooting – A Growing Leftist Trend
February 27, 2018
A prelude to later posts on the Parkland shooting and Broward County school policy. I argue that a growing swath of leftists aims less at good policy than at being seen as virtuous by fellow leftists and the glitterati, and that this virtue-signaling trend is harmful.
Crime, Punishment, and Fairness
March 16, 2018
I defend punishing crime even when someone’s environment helped form the criminal, a question made timely by the Parkland shooting and leftist attacks on punishment. Because a felony requires a guilty mind, I argue, punishment can still serve deterrence, public protection, and other aims of justice.
Slowing the “School-to-Prison Pipeline”—At What Cost?
March 29, 2018
I argue that Broward County’s effort to slow the “school-to-prison pipeline” was a classic case of ignoring tradeoffs, and that those policies helped create conditions that made a school shooting more likely. Policymakers, I argue, should adopt such ideas only if the risk-adjusted benefits clearly exceed the harms.
Trump’s tariffs (2018)
Published March 2, 2018 – March 4, 2018.
Trump’s Tariffs—A Sad Realization
March 2, 2018
I call March 1, 2018, a sad day, because Trump’s steel and aluminum tariffs showed either crony capitalism or a populist misunderstanding of trade. Nearly all economists, I argue, hold that free trade is better for the economy, jobs, and wages, even when other countries restrict trade.
A Follow Up to “Trump’s Tariffs”
March 4, 2018
A follow-up sharing Mark Perry’s account of earlier steel tariffs, including estimates of huge consumer losses per job saved. I argue that paying the affected steelworkers directly would have been less damaging than tariffs that raised costs for everyone who uses steel and invited retaliation.
The Luminous and the Shady
March 31, 2018
I share a passage from Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables on compassion and the shaky line between the fortunate and the unfortunate. It fits the blog’s aim of seeking clarity on timeless issues.
The Benefits of Work to the Worker—A Timeless Issue
April 8, 2018
I set a Victor Hugo insight beside an EconTalk conversation with Edward Glaeser on joblessness. Beyond the usual economic and moral case for work, I highlight the non-monetary benefits of work to the worker himself.
Free Markets and Morality
Published May 10, 2018 – May 27, 2018.
Free Markets and Morality—PART I
May 10, 2018
Part I answers Pope Francis’s claim in Evangelii Gaudium that an economy of “exclusion and inequality” kills. Capitalism is not paradise, but I argue that stressing only its faults, and ignoring its strengths and the human realities behind it, distorts its moral worth and promotes collectivism.
Free Markets and Morality—PART II
May 27, 2018
Part II places the Pope’s economic proposals in historical context. I argue that countries with a Judeo-Christian heritage and a stronger adherence to free-market capitalism have delivered far better results for the poor than more collectivist or non-capitalist systems.
Something to celebrate this Memorial Day.
May 28, 2018
A Memorial Day note, with a Cafe Hayek quotation, that poor Americans have access to diets once reserved for kings. I argue that, for all its faults, America is among the greatest places to live in history, and that we should remember those who died to make that possible.
Exploitation
Published June 10, 2018 – September 9, 2018.
Exploitation—Part I, The Bay For Justice
June 10, 2018
Part I begins a series on “exploitation,” sparked by a friend’s claim that the West’s success was built on naked exploitation rather than better ideas. I start sorting out what exploitation means, and why conflating punishment with compensation leads to unjust demands for redress.
Exploitation-Part II, Reparations—Calculating A Fair Amount.
June 21, 2018
Part II asks what a fair reparations amount for colonization would even be. I argue that many calls for reparations skip hard questions about the proper sum, who should pay, who should receive it, and whether the payments would actually help.
Exploitation-Part III, The Dangers of Incorrectly Detecting Exploitation
July 6, 2018
Part III turns to the dangers of loosely detecting “exploitation,” which is a subjective charge and easy to abuse. I argue that activists now apply the word to almost any pay or working condition they dislike, which muddles real injustice with ordinary market outcomes.
Exploitation—Part IV (a), Exploiting Exploitation−The Cause
August 21, 2018
Part IV (a) begins a case study: the late-1990s campaign against Nike’s Indonesian “sweatshop,” which helped launch the modern anti-sweatshop movement. I describe what well-intended activists did, setting up later posts on their arguments and the harm done to the poor people they meant to help.
Exploitation—Part IV (b), Exploiting Exploitation−The “Arguments”
August 25, 2018
Part IV (b) examines the activists’ tactics and supposed arguments, such as publishing shocking videos of factory conditions. I argue that those appeals felt persuasive but were illogical, and that they convinced the public without explaining how the campaign would actually help the poorest workers.
Exploitation—Part IV (c), Exploiting Exploitation−The Path To Prosperity
August 29, 2018
Part IV (c) asks what actually moves a poor country toward prosperity. I argue that activists picked on rich-country firms without understanding the institutions—rule of law, property rights, free markets, and the like—that poor countries need, so their prescriptions were likely to be counterproductive.
Exploitation—Part IV (d), Exploiting Exploitation−The Effects
September 6, 2018
Part IV (d) explains how the anti-sweatshop movement caused net harm. Higher costs and reputational fear discouraged factories in places that needed more of them, helping a relatively small number of workers at the expense of a vastly larger number of poor people.
Exploitation—Part IV (e), Exploiting Exploitation−Additional Negative Effects
September 9, 2018
Part IV (e) adds further self-defeating effects, including the displacement of the lowest-skilled workers when pay and conditions are forced up. Over time, I argue, more-skilled outsiders take those jobs, so the least-advantaged people the movement claimed to help are often the ones pushed out.
Nike’ Mistake—Supporting a Counterproductive Cause Against Police
September 26, 2018
By making Colin Kaepernick a “Just Do It” star, Nike aligned itself with Kaepernick’s and Black Lives Matter’s police message. I argue that the real mistake, beyond the usual culture-war arguments, is that this message and the tactics around it make things worse for the people they are supposed to help.
From a formerly respected newspaper.
September 29, 2018
I share an item that arrived from The Washington Post and say that this kind of presentation of the facts does not earn the paper its special free-press rights, pointing back to my earlier post on the New York Times.
Not So Fast On Fingering Flake
October 6, 2018
I push back on a Facebook attack calling Senator Jeff Flake a “traitor” for delaying the Kavanaugh vote for a further FBI inquiry. I argue the delay was more likely a way to blunt Democrats’ claim that Republicans were rushing and blocking an investigation.
Welfare Wreckage
October 22, 2018
Commenting on a FEE article about Lyndon Johnson’s War on Poverty, I argue that the welfare system trapped many of the people it was meant to help. Americans mainly disagree about how much aid to give and how, and the human toll of that trap deserves more attention than the usual talking points.
Nationalism
Published November 17, 2018 – June 30, 2019.
Nationalism—PART I
November 17, 2018
Part I, prompted by Emmanuel Macron’s claim that nationalism is the opposite of patriotism, sorts out what “nationalism” means. I argue that love of one’s own group is a normal human trait, that the word has been loaded with unfairly negative connotations, and that the idea matters to a decent society.
Nationalism—PART II, False Premise
December 6, 2018
Part II takes up the hysteria after Trump called himself a nationalist. I argue that critics are relying on a false premise: loyalty to a nation does not mean believing the nation is perfect, or endorsing every ugly association now attached to the word.
Nationalism PART III, Imperialism
January 5, 2019
Part III separates nationalism from imperialism. Imperialism has many causes, I argue, and nationalist feeling is only one possible factor, not an essential precondition, so the two should not be treated as the same thing.
Nationalism PART IV, Nationalism and Tribalism
June 12, 2019
Part IV answers the charge that nationalism is bad because it promotes tribalism. Tribalism has costs, I argue, but so does every form of governance, and the serious claim would have to be that some viable alternative produces less harm—which I argue has not been shown.
Nationalism PART V, Nix Nationalism?
June 27, 2019
Part V asks whether we should abandon nationalism because nation-states fall far short of the ideal. I argue that independent national states have survived the test of time and, on balance, beat chaos and the other systems tried so far, even though no policy set will create paradise.
Nationalism PART VI, Nationalism or One World Government?
June 30, 2019
Part VI, the series’ main comparison, weighs nationalism against a “one world government.” I argue that national, capitalist democratic republics have produced better and more moral results for more of their people than the alternatives, and I am skeptical that a world government is a safe or proven replacement, even given the dangers of modern weapons.
Choosing Diversity over Competence
July 31, 2019
Resignations at the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee over a lack of “diversity,” and Justin Trudeau’s gender-balanced cabinet, illustrate a choice of demographic balance over competence. I argue that shrinking the candidate pool that way makes it less likely the best person will be chosen, which is not a claim that women or minorities are less able.
Free Speech and Big Tech
Published August 14, 2019 – October 22, 2019.
Free Speech and Big Tech – The Problem
August 14, 2019
Part one of a series on Big Tech and speech: companies such as Google now have enormous power to shape what people see, including political search results. I argue that this threatens the open exchange of ideas that Enlightenment institutions used to protect, and that the threat to a free republic is severe.
Free Speech and Big Tech – The Most Negative Consequence
August 30, 2019
Unless that concentrated power is checked, I argue, the likely result is the end of free societies. Big Tech can promote or bury speech, ban people from the main platforms, and gather compromising information, which is an awesome and dangerous combination.
Free Speech and Big Tech – How To Make Things Worse
September 8, 2019
The usual reaction—demanding more government regulation of misbehaving firms—would make this problem worse. Regulation, I argue, is often captured by the industry itself, protects incumbents, and would hand still more power to a government that already has too much; even Mark Zuckerberg’s call for more rules is a warning sign.
Free Speech and Big Tech – The Conundrum
October 1, 2019
The conundrum is that we cannot live with Big Tech’s ideological policing of speech, and we also cannot simply live without the platforms. I review evidence that the companies’ leadership is overwhelmingly left-leaning and that this bias shapes what users see.
Free Speech and Big Tech – The Legislative Betrayal
October 11, 2019
Before asking what to do, I examine Section 230 and the special legal immunity Congress gave platforms. That bargain, I argue, let Big Tech host speech without the liability of a publisher while still moderating like one, and it helped make today’s broad infringements on speech possible.
Free Speech and Big Tech – What To Do
October 22, 2019
I argue there is no complete solution, only tradeoffs, and that the law should be changed as little as possible but as much as necessary to break the Section 230 bargain that lets platforms suppress disfavored speech. Letting government itself moderate speech, as I said earlier, would make matters worse.
Fix Climate Change For The Children!
October 24, 2019
A Facebook dismissal of a climate article as “conservative-biased” proves nothing, because the other side is biased too, as are agencies and journals that reward some findings over others. Given that uncertainty, I argue it is irresponsible to demand huge resources “for the children” on climate remedies that may do less for our grandchildren than other uses of the same money.
Medicare for All
Published November 11, 2019 – February 7, 2020.
The Selfish Leftist Heart
November 11, 2019
Leftists often accuse others of heartlessness, but their “Medicare for All” offers, I argue, reveal a narrower selfishness. They propose coverage only for already-rich Americans, not for the much poorer people in the rest of the world, while still congratulating themselves for supporting a “human right.”
The Immorality of Medicare For Less Than All
December 2, 2019
A follow-up: “Medicare for All” is a misleading name for a plan that covers only people in America. Many supporters think they are backing a moral cause, but I argue they have not actually made a moral case, and that empathy alone does not make the policy right.
Why Not Provide Medicare To Everyone In The World?
December 8, 2019
If the moral claim were serious, the demand would be Medicare for everyone in the world—and I argue that idea is immoral too. A policy that does more harm than good is a bad policy even if its benefits sound immense, and supporting it without facing those harms is irresponsible.
Medicare For All? At What Cost To Us and The Rest Of The World?
December 26, 2019
I argue Medicare for All would hurt the world, not just America. Americans’ high drug prices help pay for new medicines, and cutting that funding would slow the cures on which people everywhere depend.
Medicare for All Americans—The Balance of Power.
February 7, 2020
The deepest political question is how to keep a livable balance of power between governors and the governed. I argue that ceding control of healthcare to the government would shift that balance too far toward the state, with risks of tyranny that history makes all too clear.
About the Trump Articles of Impeachment
January 20, 2020
The White House response to the impeachment articles missed an argument about justice: an ex post facto standard is wrong. I argue it is unjust to punish Trump under a newly revived rule when similar presidential conduct had long been common and unpunished, and that the articles are therefore an unjustifiable wrong.
The Right Time to Invest In the Stock Market
March 6, 2020
Prompted by a sharp market drop, I caution readers against the panic selling and market timing I have watched people regret for decades. I am not a professional analyst, but I argue that a long-term approach that pays little attention to short-term swings beats trying to guess the right moment to buy or sell.
COVID-19 ★
Published March 21, 2020 – October 6, 2020. Includes the numbered series “The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19,” related data and policy posts, and a later New York Times follow-up. They are listed here in the order they were published, with the numbered parts kept in part order.
COVID-19 and the Economic Reality of Preparedness
March 21, 2020
Italy’s struggle to ration intensive care during COVID-19 shows what scarce medical resources actually mean. I argue that no system can give everyone every treatment in a surge, so preparedness and economic capacity, not slogans, determine how much care a country can deliver.
Dr. Fauci Follies
April 4, 2020
Dr. Fauci’s call for stay-at-home orders in every state went beyond an epidemiologist’s expertise, and he admitted he did not understand why some states had not issued them. I argue that health and the economy are not opposites in the COVID-19 debate, and that experts should not be followed blindly outside their field.
COVID-19—THE DATA or “the data”?
April 6, 2020
I argue that the Johns Hopkins “Total Confirmed” counts being treated as “the data” are much less informative than they look. The number that would actually reveal the danger is how many people have been infected, not how many cases have been confirmed, and the headline figures are easy to misuse.
Coronavirus Proves It: We Need Medicare For All?
April 15, 2020
Leftist commentary claimed the pandemic proved the need for Medicare for All, but I have yet to hear a logical explanation of why. I argue the claim would require showing that universal systems handled COVID-19 better than America’s, and I preview a data-based reply.
It Was “the data.”
April 18, 2020
A follow-up to my post on COVID data: early antibody studies, including work described by Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, found a death rate far below Dr. Fauci’s March testimony and closer to that of the flu. That, I argue, confirms how misleading “confirmed cases” were as a measure of danger.
The Data On Coronavirus Does Not Prove We Need Medicare For All
April 19, 2020
I compare COVID-19 deaths per capita in the United States with those in the European countries that had the most confirmed cases. Deaths, I argue, are a better test than case counts, and the numbers do not show that the pandemic proved America needs Medicare for All.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part I
April 24, 2020
Part I of a series on the real COVID-19 issues: the daily fights over lockdowns and reopening are sideshows. The hard problem is balancing two goals that pull against each other—limiting the damage from the virus and keeping the economy from falling past the point of no return.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part II
April 26, 2020
Part II describes how officials and the press used a frightening publicity campaign to get people to follow restrictions, which may have been understandable given bad early data. The resulting fear, I argue, now makes reopening harder, because businesses cannot recover if customers remain too afraid to show up.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part III
May 2, 2020
Part III catalogs harms from the interventions themselves, including delayed care, lost income, and the poor record of coronavirus vaccines. I argue that a cure is far from assured, and that the health costs of the restrictions belong in the balance alongside the virus.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part IV, The Herd Immunity Messaging Problem
May 7, 2020
Part IV, “The Herd Immunity Messaging Problem,” argues that official talk treating every rise in infections as simply bad is unscientific and delays recovery. If the experts I cite are right, I argue, that messaging does a poor job of protecting the vulnerable and of letting immunity build among those at much lower risk.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part V, The Good News
May 11, 2020
Part V turns to good news that fear has crowded out, including how selectively severe COVID-19 is by age and health. Those quirks, I argue, should inform a more targeted policy that eases blanket restrictions sooner rather than later.
To Mask Or Not To Mask?
May 17, 2020
I argue that masks do both good and harm, so the claim that they do no good is wrong. They can block some virus, but viral load matters, and a mask can also trap and recycle particles back to the wearer.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part V, About The Drumbeat For COVID-19 Testing
May 18, 2020
A short correction: this post was mislabeled Part V and should have been Part VI. I point readers to the correctly titled copy and apologize for the inconvenience.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part VI, About The Drumbeat For COVID-19 Testing
May 19, 2020
Part VI, prompted by a Russ Roberts interview of Paul Romer, challenges the drumbeat for widespread COVID-19 testing as the key to making people comfortable enough to resume commerce. I argue that the usual case for testing does not actually show how or why it would produce that confidence.
Texas Reopening — The Data
June 1, 2020
Before Texas eased restrictions, critics predicted a slaughter if the state reopened. I look at Texas data before and after the easing and argue that those forecasts were not borne out, and that the critics never showed how slowing spread would reduce eventual deaths once hospitals were not overwhelmed.
The Real Issues Concerning COVID-19—Part VII, Dr. Katz To The Rescue!
June 16, 2020
Part VII argues that official experts sowed confusion, moved the goalposts on “flattening the curve,” and never offered a practical exit from the restrictions they had urged. I point to Dr. David Katz as someone offering a more useful way to protect the vulnerable and reopen in a reasonably safe and economically effective way.
Dr. Fauci, The Stone Caster
July 9, 2020
When Dr. Fauci said some states “opened up too early,” I argue he was throwing stones from a glass house. He defends his own early calls as the best that could be done with limited information, while evidence has accumulated that the mitigation measures also killed and damaged many people.
The Truth Is Still Hard For The New York Times.
October 6, 2020
A follow-up to my 2017 New York Times post, about a Times piece that used deaths-per-million charts to claim other rich countries had fought COVID-19 much more successfully than the United States. I argue the comparison is unreliable, including because, as Dr. Birx had noted, U.S. numbers are not counted the same way.
Preventing Stock Buy Backs—A Bad Idea
March 23, 2020
Trump’s idea of barring bailout funds from being used for stock buybacks, I argue, targets a non-problem at a bad time. Buybacks move idle cash from firms with no good use for it to investors who can fund firms that do, which helps workers and consumers rather than wasting the money.
About All The Planned Government Spending
March 26, 2020
I warn that planned new trillions in federal spending are a big deal on top of already untenable debt and unfunded liabilities. Both parties, I argue, have talked out of both sides of their mouths on the debt, and the public’s indifference makes the problem worse.
Bernie, the Bad Guy
April 2, 2020
A social-media tribute to Bernie Sanders treats his wish for education, health care, and good jobs for everyone as if that made him unique. I argue almost everyone wants those things; what makes the socialist program harmful is the false belief that government can wish them into being, and the waste of chasing that impossible dream.
Biden’s Bigotry
May 24, 2020
Joe Biden’s remark that “you ain’t black” if you support Trump reveals, I argue, both self-interest and what George W. Bush called the soft bigotry of low expectations. Biden presumes to judge who counts as black and implies that black Americans cannot think or choose for themselves without people like him.
@Unity2020
July 15, 2020
I call attention to the Articles of Unity, or @Unity2020, a plan to elect a ticket of one centrist conservative and one centrist liberal. I argue that lesser-of-two-evils presidential choices have grown worse, and that the country needs competent patriots rather than candidates whose main skill is evasion and division.
What’s Going On? / Black Lives Do Matter ★
Published July 18, 2020 – December 12, 2020. A ten-part series. Part I frames the unrest after George Floyd’s death; Parts II–X are written under the heading “Black Lives Do Matter.”
What’s Going On? – Part I The Mess
July 18, 2020
Part I of a series on the unrest after George Floyd’s death, which I treat as a possible turning point. I survey the visible forces in play—protests, BLM demands, radical education, and more—and argue that even this partial list is reason to worry about whether the republic can be kept.
What’s Going On? – Part II Black Lives Do Matter, Problems Aplenty
July 23, 2020
Part II, under the heading “Black Lives Do Matter,” grants that black Americans face a disproportionate share of serious problems and that many BLM grievances are legitimate. I begin listing those problems, including unequal treatment and crime, and note that some important ones get too little attention.
What’s Going On? – Part III Black Lives Do Matter, The “Do-Gooders’” Slate
August 2, 2020
Part III argues that open racists are few and largely powerless, and that well-intended progressive “Do-Gooders” have done far more harm to black Americans over the past half-century. I trace much of that damage to the War on Poverty and preview later posts on how those policies went wrong.
What’s Going On? – Part IV Black Lives Do Matter, Do-Gooders’ War On Poverty
August 15, 2020
Part IV is about how the War on Poverty derailed progress blacks had been making and helped produce today’s grievances. I argue that many current prescriptions merely double down on those failed policies, which hurt people of every race but are now central to the story BLM tells.
What’s Going On? – Part V Black Lives Do Matter, Unfair Discriminatory Structures
August 29, 2020
Part V asks whether the War on Poverty should be called “structural racism.” I argue that would be a mistake even though the policy did lasting harm: the civil-rights laws that struck down real Jim Crow barriers were not enough to offset the damage, and “racism” is the wrong word for a program whose stated aim was not racial domination.
What’s Going On? – Part VI Black Lives Do Matter, The Stereotyping Problem
September 12, 2020
Part VI turns to negative stereotyping, or racial profiling, a cruel problem that is not mainly the product of government policy. I argue that most such stereotyping is not the contemptible racist kind, and that misunderstanding why it happens is why so many attempts to fix it have failed.
What’s Going On? – Part VII Black Lives Do Matter, Dashed Hopes
September 27, 2020
Part VII argues that one of the most damaging results of repeated policy failures is dashed hope. Before the War on Poverty, blacks were making rapid gains and had more hope; broken promises, I argue, breed pessimism that saps motivation and even health, making later progress harder.
What’s Going On? – Part VIII Black Lives Do Matter, BLM Misdirection
October 8, 2020
Part VIII argues that a movement to address blacks’ valid grievances is necessary, but that BLM is not that movement. It spends attention and resources on causes not unique to black Americans, I argue, and many of its initiatives actually harm the people it claims to put first.
What’s Going On? – Part IX Black Lives Do Matter, BLM Misdiagnosis — Police Are The Problem
November 13, 2020
Part IX begins a look at BLM’s misdiagnoses, starting with the claim that the police are the core problem. I argue that a higher share of black Americans are killed by police does not prove a “war on black people” unless one also accounts for differences in violent-crime rates, and that blaming police first misstates the evidence.
What’s Going On? – Part X Black Lives Do Matter, BLM Misdiagnosis — Disparity Delusions
December 12, 2020
Part X takes up the claim that racial disparities are themselves proof of current oppression. Black Americans did suffer severe oppression in the past, I argue, but today’s gaps have other important causes as well—including patterns such as COVID-19 risk—and treating every disparity as oppression is a delusion that leads to the wrong remedies.
Another California Bust
August 19, 2020
California’s law treating ride-hailing drivers as employees, rather than independent contractors, led Uber and Lyft to suspend operations, putting hundreds of thousands of drivers out of that work. I argue this is another case of a well-intended rule that harms the drivers, customers, and businesses it was supposed to help.
/The Social Dilemma – A Review
September 19, 2020
A review of Netflix’s The Social Dilemma, which I found informative on how addictive and manipulative social media has become. It sharpens the “can’t live with or without it” problem I discussed in my Big Tech series, and it leaves me more open to limited rules on the use of personal data, though not to partisan content control.
Was Supporting Trump A Mistake?
January 8, 2021
Asked whether supporting Trump was a mistake after an awful stretch of events, I sort out why many Trump voters still say it was worth it. I have never been a Trump supporter, but I agree that he was the only candidate who could beat Hillary Clinton, and that taking a chance on him was worth it for that reason.
We Have A Problem
January 9, 2021
Trouble reaching Parler, followed by Apple’s and Google’s threats and bans, shows how much speech now depends on a few tech companies. I argue that if Big Tech does what a newly unified government wants, Lord Acton’s warning about power and corruption is on display.
Silencing of the Lambs and Wolves
January 10, 2021
A comment that Amazon’s decision to stop hosting Parler was a “business move, not political” misses the point. I argue that it does not matter why firms help shut down disfavored speech; once the powerful honor demands to silence others, the bans spread and the rules become a tool of punishment.
A Theory About Conspiracy Theories
January 11, 2021
I offer a theory that one of the most useful tactics for would-be tyrants was teaching Americans to treat any claim of secret government collusion as automatically false and crazy. People in government do conspire in the ordinary sense of the word, I argue, and classified programs and closed hearings are enough to show that hidden collective action is real.
The Last Morning in America
January 20, 2021
On Inauguration Day 2021, I write that this may be “the last morning in America,” meaning the end of the founding experiment in limited, constitutional government. I fear that experiment may not survive one-party control, even though America, for all its failures, has been the wealthiest, most inventive, and most generous nation ever.
The Bamboozling of Americans About Jan. 6 ★
Published October 3, 2024 – December 19, 2024. Several installments share the same official title. The part labels below come from the posts themselves. The October 9, 2024 post is a longer published treatment that overlaps Part I and later discussions of framing techniques.
The Bamboozling of Americans About Jan. 6 – Part I: Introduction
October 3, 2024
Part I of a 2024 series asks why Americans are so divided about January 6, 2021, and why that divide mattered to the 2024 election. I do not claim to know whether the events were a Deep State PSYOP, but I argue that much of the mainstream narrative was false or misleading, and that dismissing the PSYOP possibility shows a lack of curiosity.
The Bamboozling of Americans About Jan. 6 — A longer published treatment of the introduction
October 9, 2024
A longer published treatment that restates the Part I introduction, then sets out preliminary concessions about what is and is not known and discusses the “Disinformers’” framing techniques, overlapping material developed in later parts.
The Bamboozling of Americans About Jan. 6 — PART II – The Disinformers’ Drivel
October 16, 2024
Part II, “The Disinformers’ Drivel,” takes up three go-to replies: that a PSYOP claim is just a conspiracy theory, that January 6 was an insurrection, and that Trump should be prosecuted for it. I argue each of those replies fails, including the claim that Trump’s speech urged an insurrection.
PART III – The Disinformers’ Bamboozling Techniques
October 30, 2024
Part III explains how media and the Deep State used framing techniques, especially priming, to shape what the public thought it was seeing on January 6. I describe those techniques so readers can recognize them.
The Bamboozling of Americans About Jan. 6 — PART IV – Bamboozlement About The 2020 Election Vote Count
December 16, 2024
Part IV turns to the 2020 vote count and the motives of the people who marched to the Capitol. I argue they believed the count was illegitimate, that protesting on that belief was a protected right, and that claims Trump urged an insurrection are preposterous in light of his call to make their voices heard “peacefully and patriotically.”
The Bamboozling of Americans About Jan. 6 — PART V: An addendum to PART IV
December 19, 2024
Part V is an addendum to Part IV on wording. I argue that officials repeatedly said there was no evidence of widespread “voter fraud,” a narrow term about individual voters, rather than “election fraud,” and that this choice of words misled the public about what had and had not been disproved.
The Comically Cowardly Climate Catastrophizers’ Conundrum
March 12, 2026
I argue that the fatal flaw in Net Zero advocacy is not just the hypocrisy of celebrity travel, but that the policy has no real chance of working. Global CO2 emissions have kept rising, and the IPCC’s own 2050 pathways show the prescribed course was already off track.